The Controversy Between Controlled Drinking And Abstinence

Alcoholism is a prominent substance abuse issue in Western society. The treatment method of controlled drinking as opposed to abstinence is a continuing cause of controversy in alcohol research to this day. The US is different from Europe in its acceptance of controlled drinking as a goal of treatment: â€Å"in the US alcohol dependence is typically depicted as a ‘recurring disease’ and the ‘successful abstainer’ as a ‘recovering’ though never ‘recovered’ alcoholic† (Coldwell, 2005). Depending on the alcohol abuse patient’s individual characteristics, either controlled drinking or abstinence is chosen as a treatment. Alcohol treatment in Canada, however seems to incorporate both mechanisms as shown in the study by Rush and Ogborne (1986).The study states that goals for one third of clients who were non abstinent were accepted depending on whether it was a residential or community-based outpatient service. Other effective methods in treating alcoholism are pharmacotherapy, behavioral method and self help manuals. This paper will discuss different therapeutic interventions while highlighting the controversy between controlled drinking and abstinence. Alcohol abuse is growing rapidly throughout U.S. society. One in every twelve adults is being diagnosed with alcohol abuse (Barlow and Durand, 2006). All that are diagnosed with alcohol abuse must meet one or more of the following criteria within a twelve month period: he/ she must fail to accomplish major work, school or homeShow MoreRelated Alcohol Research Essay2723 Words   |  11 Pagesmethod of controlled drinking as opposed to abstinence is a continuing cause of controversy in alcohol research to this day. The US is different from Europe in its acceptance of controlled drinking as a goal of treatment: â€Å"in the US alcohol dependence is typically depicted as a ‘recurring disease’ and the ‘successful abstainer’ as a ‘recovering’ though never ‘recovered’ alcoholic† (Coldwell, 2005). Depending on the alcohol abuse patient’s individual characteristics, either controlled drinking or abstinenceRead MoreCurrent Tren ds in Drug and Alcohol Addiction Essay1469 Words   |  6 Pagesand cannabinoids. These classes contain drugs that either stimulate or depress, and in some instances may exhibit both (Types of Drugs, 2013, Para. 4, Para. 5, Para. 6). Controlled substance is a term given by governments and agencies to label drugs that have a high probability of abuse (Get Informed, 2014, Para. 1). Controlled substances are then divided into two categories, drugs that have useful medical purposes, and drugs that do not have useful medical purposes. The substances with medical valueRead MoreCommon Pharmacological Treatments For Alcohol Dependence1803 Words   |  8 PagesThe best-known effectiveness of Disulfiram is restraining alcohol consumption by bringing detriment to drinking experience. According to Chowdary and Carnwath (2008), Disulfiram stops the process that converts alcohol to acetaldehyde and then acetate. It makes acetaldehyde accumulated and results in alcohol-dependence patients’ discomfort when consuming alcohol. Moreover, a comparative trial between Disulfiram and Vitamin C (as cited in Chick et al., 1992) points out that Disulfiram under supervisionRead More what is the right drinking age? Essay2094 Words   |  9 Pageslowering the drinking age back to eighteen will lead to a domino affect of bad premonitions like rampant drinking binges, raving alcoholics, and more traffic accident deaths upon the entire nation. Realistic Alcohol Laws for Legal Youth (RALLY) is one of many major organizations dedicated to rectifying these faulty perspectives that Americans hold. Due to the irrelevance on the number of alcohol related car accidents in the 1970?s, the parents obligation to teach responsible drinking, and the factRead MorePublic Health Problem Of The United States1677 Words   |  7 Pages341-342). This stigmatism has caused individuals to be wary and reluctant to go get tested. Thus infected individuals unknowingly transmit the disease to uninfected individuals. In addition to stigmatism, there is also public criticism over the controversy of discussing about sex in public. Americans generally do not like to have their rights and freedoms infringed by the government, and for many, sex is something most people oppose having regulated or mentioned in politics and social media. SimultaneouslyRead MoreA Traditional 12 Step Aa Meeting1879 Words   |  8 Pagesthey may solve their common problem and help others to recover from alcoholism. The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking. There are no dues or fees for AA membership; we are self-supporting through our own contributions. AA is not allied with any sect, denomination, politics, organi zation or institution; does not wish to engage in any controversy; neither endorses nor opposes any causes. Our primary purpose is to stay sober and help other alcoholics to achieve sobriety.† AfterRead MoreEye Movement Desensitization Reprocessing ( Emdr )6741 Words   |  27 Pagesassociated with an intense fear response. In the treatment of alcohol use disorders, as well as other substance use disorders, extinction training aims to reduce the cravings instigated by objects or situations that the patient associates with alcohol or drinking. The extinction training for both PTSD and AUD is intended to reduce the consolidated responses of fear or alcohol craving to the stimuli that would normally instigate the condition dependent response in the patient. Drawbacks of Extinction. OneRead MoreSda Manual Essay101191 Words   |  405 Pagesglorious church, not having spot, or wrinkle, or any such thing; but that it should be holy and without blemish† (Eph. 5:27). No Wall of Partition Christ sought by precept and example to teach the truth that with God there was to be no dividing wall between Israel and the other nations (John 4:4-42; 10:16; Luke 9:51-56; Matt. 15:21-28). The apostle Paul wrote, â€Å"The Gentiles are fellow heirs, members of the same body, and 3 4 CHURCH MANUAL partakers of the promise in Christ Jesus throughRead More_x000C_Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis355457 Words   |  1422 Pagesgraduated from Iowa State University with a major in mathematics and, while acquiring graduate degrees at the University of Iowa, concentrated on statistics, computer programming, psychometrics, and test development. Currently, he divides his duties between teaching and evaluation; in addition to teaching, he is the assessment facilitator for the Cedar Rapids, Iowa, Community Schools. In his spare time he enjoys reading and hiking. He and his wife have a daughter, Anna, who is a graduate student in Civil